Police Misconduct – Excessive Force
1. Definition
A Section 1983 excessive force case alleges that a government officer (usually a police officer or jail/prison official), acting under color of state law, used force beyond what the U.S. Constitution allows. The Amendment that applies depends on the person’s status at the time of the force:
- Fourth Amendment — force used during an arrest, investigatory stop, or other “seizure” of a free person.
- Fourteenth Amendment (Due Process) — force against a pretrial detainee (post-arrest, pre-conviction).
- Eighth Amendment — force against a convicted prisoner.
Each Amendment has its own test and evidentiary focus.
2. Florida Legal Context
Fourth Amendment (street encounters, arrests)
- Standard: Objective reasonableness under the totality of the circumstances (no inquiry into the officer’s subjective intent). Courts weigh factors such as the severity of the alleged crime, whether the person posed an immediate threat, and whether they were resisting or fleeing. Deadly force is limited to situations where there is probable cause the person poses a significant threat of death or serious physical injury.
- Timing matters: Reasonableness is assessed at the moment force was used, not with hindsight.
Fourteenth Amendment (pretrial detainees)
- Standard: Objective unreasonableness (no need to prove malice). Courts consider the relationship between the need for force and the amount used, the extent of injury, efforts to temper or limit the force, the threat reasonably perceived, and any security concerns in the jail setting.
Eighth Amendment (convicted prisoners)
- Standard: Whether the force was applied maliciously and sadistically to cause harm (as opposed to a good-faith effort to maintain or restore discipline). Even modest injury can be actionable if the force was wanton.
Qualified Immunity (QI)
- Officers are shielded unless (1) the facts show a constitutional violation, and (2) the right was clearly established at the time. In the Eleventh Circuit (covering Florida), cases repeatedly hold that gratuitous force against a non-resisting, restrained person violates clearly established law.
Municipal Liability (Monell)
- Cities/counties are not vicariously liable for an officer’s conduct. A plaintiff must prove an official policy, custom, or failure to train/supervise that caused the violation. Punitive damages are not available against municipalities (they are possible against individual officers in appropriate cases).
Limitations & Fees (Florida specifics)
- Limitations: § 1983 borrows Florida’s personal-injury limitations period — generally four years for most excessive-force claims.
- Attorney’s Fees: Prevailing plaintiffs may recover reasonable fees and costs under 42 U.S.C. § 1988.
Eleventh Circuit examples frequently used in Florida cases include findings of excessive force where officers used force after a suspect was handcuffed or compliant, or where less-lethal munitions were deployed against a person who did not pose an immediate threat.
3. Real-World Application
- Fourth Amendment (street): Taser deployments, baton strikes, K-9 bites, choke/neck restraints, or firearm use against a person who is not posing an immediate threat, is already restrained, or has ceased resistance. Vehicle ramming/shootings hinge on the immediacy and magnitude of the threat.
- Fourteenth Amendment (jail intake/holding): Force used to punish or retaliate rather than to address a legitimate security need; failure to temper force when a detainee is restrained.
- Eighth Amendment (prisons): Beatings, K-9 attacks, or chemical agents used maliciously and sadistically, especially after order is restored.
Evidence that moves the needle: body-cam/dash-cam video, civilian phone video, 911/CAD audio, Axon/TASER logs, K-9 bite-duration records, use-of-force and training policies, internal affairs files, GPS data, medical records, and photographs. These cases turn on objective facts.
4. Why It Matters for Business Clients
- Fast preservation is critical: Body-cam video and electronic logs can be overwritten. Immediate preservation demands reduce spoliation fights and strengthen the case.
- Correct standard = correct strategy: Applying the right Amendment (Fourth vs. Fourteenth vs. Eighth) controls the proof required and the likelihood of defeating Qualified Immunity.
- Who you can sue: Individual officers (damages + potential punitives) and municipalities only via a Monell policy/custom/failure-to-train theory.
- Florida timing: Most claims must be filed within four years of the force event—do not delay.
5. How Our Law Firm Can Help
- Rapid evidence lockdown: We immediately send preservation letters for body-cam/dash-cam, dispatch/CAD audio, Axon/TASER logs, K-9 records, training materials, internal affairs files, and any nearby surveillance footage.
- Case theory & experts: We align the facts to the correct constitutional standard and retain police-practices, force-science, and medical experts to analyze reasonableness, injury, and causation.
- Beat Qualified Immunity: We pair your facts with controlling Supreme Court and Eleventh Circuit precedent demonstrating that the right was clearly established.
- Monell track: Where warranted, we build the policy/custom/failure-to-train case through complaint histories, pattern evidence, supervision gaps, and training deficiencies.
- Full-spectrum relief: We pursue compensatory damages, § 1988 fees, and punitive damages against individuals where appropriate, while coordinating any parallel criminal or disciplinary proceedings.
6. FAQs (Frequently Asked Questions)
Q1: Which Amendment applies to my case?
It depends on your status when the force occurred: street arrest/stop (Fourth), pretrial detention (Fourteenth), or post-conviction custody (Eighth).
Q2: What makes force “excessive” under the Fourth Amendment?
Force is unlawful if, objectively, it was more than necessary under the circumstances—looking at threat level, severity of the offense, and resistance/flight. Deadly force requires a significant, immediate threat.
Q3: Can I sue the city or sheriff’s office?
Yes, but not just because an officer erred. You must prove a policy, custom, or failure to train caused the violation (Monell). Municipalities cannot be hit with punitive damages.
Q4: What is Qualified Immunity, and can it be overcome?
QI shields officers unless the constitutional right was clearly established. We overcome QI by showing prior cases with similar facts (e.g., gratuitous force on a restrained, non-resisting person) and by developing strong, objective evidence.
Q5: How long do I have to file?
Generally four years in Florida for § 1983 excessive-force claims (measured from the date of the incident).
Q6: What evidence should I gather now?
Medical records, photos of injuries, names/contact info for witnesses, incident numbers, and any video you or others captured. Contact us immediately so we can send formal preservation demands before critical evidence is lost.
7. How to Retain Our Law Firm
Depending on the case type, we offer different retainer options such as:
- 1-Hour Strategy Consultations: A high-impact session with the litigation attorney to assess your legal issues, review documents, answer questions, develop a legal roadmap and provide litigation budget. Consult Fee: $500.00 for the first 1-Hour.
- Traditional Initial Retainer: Pay an upfront initial retainer, and we bill at an hourly rate. Once the initial retainer is exhausted, we require an additional retainer. Retainer amount varies on a case-by-case basis.
- Hybrid Paid Retainer: Pay an upfront initial retainer, and we bill at an hourly rate. Once we exhaust the initial retainer, you pay a flat monthly rate until the conclusion of the case.
- Hybrid Contingency Retainer: Pay a one-time upfront initial retainer, the remaining attorney compensation will be received as a contingency once the case concludes.
- Flat Fee Retainer: In certain circumstances, we may offer a flat fee litigation retainer.
- Flagship Product: BELAW – Business + Entrepreneurship Law Advisor Program). If you are a business and sign up as a BELAW Member (read below), you will receive initial litigation retainer and attorney fee discounts. Depending on your membership tier, our members may receive 50% to 100% waiver of the initial retainer.
All consultations are available in-person, by phone, or virtually. At the time of the consultation, you will officially be provided with the retainer options.
8. Flagship Product: BELAW – Business + Entrepreneurship Law Advisor Program
Our flagship service is the BELAW Membership – Business & Entrepreneurship Law Advisor Program. This is an exclusive, members-only, 12-month ON-DEMAND legal and business support program at a predictable flat monthly fee, tailored to each business client—regardless of company size.
BELAW is open to business owners, entrepreneurs, for-profit companies, non-profits, and foreign investors. Our members range from startups and nonprofits to established businesses.
At the core of BELAW is our P.O.N.C.E. methodology, developed by Attorney Gil Sanchez, to help businesses not just stay protected—but grow strategically.
What you get with BELAW:
- On demand strategic legal consultations with Attorney Gil Sanchez
- Document review and compliance audits
- Guidance on contracts, leasing, employment, and liability
- Drafting Collection Notices, Cease & Desist Letters and Confidentiality Agreements
- Proactive legal support to mitigate lawsuits and reduce risk exposure
- Strategic input on revenue-generating decisions like expansion, licensing, and joint ventures
- Entrepreneur coaching and a growing library of business education resources
- Litigation retainer and hourly rate discounts
We’re available when you need us—on demand, without hourly billing.
We make it easy to get started:
- Call or text us at (813) 254-1777
- Or fill out the secure contact form below
Click
A member of our team will respond promptly to schedule your consultation.
9. How to Contact Our Law Firm to Retain
We make it easy for you to retain us:
- Call or text: (813) 254-1777
- Email: info@blackrocklaw.com
- Or submit your request using the form below
Our team will promptly follow up to confirm availability and next steps.
10. Who You Are Hiring
When you hire our firm, you’re not just hiring a lawyer — you’re securing the insight, grit, and expertise of Attorney Gil Sanchez, a seasoned litigator who has been trying cases in courtrooms across Florida since June 2004.
Gil practices in Florida state courts and in all three Florida federal districts, with jury trial experience in both state and federal court. He has litigated against some of the largest corporations in the United States, securing justice for both individuals and businesses as plaintiffs and defendants.
Over the past two decades, Gil has successfully handled a broad spectrum of civil and commercial litigation matters, including breach of contract, fraud, negligence, business disputes, consumer rights, real estate conflicts, torts, and more. His exposure to over 10 different areas of law gives him a rare, multidimensional perspective that most trial lawyers lack — allowing him to quickly identify issues, craft compelling arguments, and outmaneuver opposing counsel.
A proud double Gator, Gil earned both his undergraduate and law degrees from the University of Florida, one of the country’s top public institutions. His unique blend of legal experience, business acumen, and real-world insight makes him not just a lawyer — but a powerful legal strategist.
Gil has been featured on CNN, ABC’s 20/20, and other major media outlets for his role in high-profile litigation. He’s also played a part in shaping Florida law, having helped pass legislation protecting the unborn — a testament to his ability to fight not only in court but also in the legislative arena.
Beyond the courtroom, Gil is a successful entrepreneur, licensed business broker (since 2007), adjunct professor of entrepreneurship, patented inventor, and bilingual advisor fluent in Spanish. His invention was featured in TIME Magazine’s Best Inventions of 2023, and his ability to connect legal, business, and personal insight means clients get more than just legal counsel — they get a trusted partner.
Most importantly, Gil is a spiritual family man — a husband and father of three — whose values of empathy, integrity, and tenacity drive every case he takes.
11. The Law Firm’s Geographical Reach
We proudly represent people and businesses across Florida. With the power of virtual consultations, online filings, and remote court access, we can support your legal needs anywhere in Florida—without compromising service quality.
Our main office is in South Tampa, Florida, with a satellite office in South Florida – Miramar, Florida.
12. Disclaimer
The information provided on this website is for general informational purposes only and is not intended to be, nor should it be construed as legal advice. Every individual and business matter involves unique facts and circumstances that must be carefully evaluated. Additionally, Florida laws, including statutes and case law, are subject to frequent changes, and the information presented here may not reflect the most current legal developments. For a formal legal opinion or advice specific to your situation, you must consult directly with an attorney at our firm. No attorney-client relationship is formed by viewing this site or by contacting our office through this website.